Jump to Recipe

Sometimes a meal doesn’t quite work the first time.

I had some lamb chops that I originally used for kebabs, but they were a little too tough for quick cooking and a little too fatty to enjoy cooked like a steak.

That doesn’t make them bad lamb.

It just means they needed a different cooking method.

And this weekend, they’re becoming something much better suited to them: a slow-cooked Lancashire-style lamb hotpot, topped with layers of thinly sliced potato that turn golden and crisp on top while the lamb cooks gently underneath.

This is exactly the kind of cooking I love because nothing needs rescuing with a complicated recipe. You simply understand what the ingredient needs and change direction.

Why Hotpot Works So Well for Tougher Lamb

Cuts with more connective tissue and fat often need time rather than high heat.

Cook them quickly and they can stay chewy.

Cook them slowly in a little stock, however, and the meat has time to soften while the fat adds flavour to the sauce.

Lancashire hotpot traditionally uses lamb or mutton layered with onions and potatoes, then cooked slowly in the oven.

The potato topping is one of the best parts. The slices underneath absorb some of the lamb and stock, while the exposed edges become beautifully golden.

It is proper cold-weather food.

Method

Heat a large frying pan over medium-high heat and brown the lamb chops on both sides. You are not trying to cook them through at this point, just adding colour and flavour.

If the chops are particularly fatty, you may not need any extra oil in the pan.

Remove the lamb and set aside.

Add the onions, leek and carrot to the same pan and cook gently until beginning to soften. Add the garlic and cook for another minute.

If you want a slightly thicker gravy, stir in a tablespoon or two of flour and cook briefly before adding the stock.

Pour in the stock and Worcestershire sauce, then add the mustard and thyme if using. Stir well and season with black pepper.

Arrange the lamb in a deep casserole dish and spoon the vegetables and stock around it. The liquid should come partway up the meat rather than completely covering it.

Peel the potatoes if you prefer, then slice them thinly.

Arrange the potato slices over the top in overlapping layers, rather like roof tiles.

Brush or dot the potatoes with a little butter or olive oil and season lightly.

Cover the casserole and cook at 160–170°C fan-forced for around 2½–3 hours, or until the lamb is tender.

Remove the lid for the final 30–40 minutes.

If the potatoes need more colour, increase the oven to around 200°C for the last 15–20 minutes, watching carefully so they become golden rather than burnt.

The exact cooking time will depend on how thick your chops are, so use tenderness rather than the clock as your guide.

Keep the Gravy Simple

This isn’t a dish that needs twenty ingredients.

The lamb, onion, potato and stock do most of the work.

A little Worcestershire sauce gives depth, and mustard adds warmth without making the dish taste particularly mustardy.

If you have herbs from the garden, thyme or rosemary both work beautifully, although I would use rosemary fairly lightly because it can dominate.

What to Serve With Lamb Hotpot

Because the hotpot is already rich and filling, I like something simple and fresh alongside it.

Steamed greens work beautifully, as do peas or cabbage with a little mustard or vinegar.

Traditionally, something sharp such as pickled red cabbage or beetroot is also lovely because it cuts through the richness of the lamb.

When the First Cooking Method Doesn’t Work

I think we are often too quick to decide an ingredient “didn’t work”.

Sometimes the ingredient is perfectly fine.

The cooking method simply wasn’t right for it.

A tough lamb chop might not be brilliant cooked quickly over high heat.

But give it a few hours in stock under potatoes and suddenly it makes complete sense.

That is one of the best parts of learning to cook more instinctively.

Instead of asking:

“What recipe was I meant to make?”

Ask:

“What does this ingredient need?”

That question can save a lot of food.

Make the Next Meal Easier

This is also a great cook-once meal.

Make a larger hotpot and portion the leftovers for lunch the next day. Like many slow-cooked dishes, the flavour is often even better after sitting overnight.

You can also cook the lamb filling ahead, cool it, then add the sliced potatoes before baking the following day.

It is exactly the sort of cold-weather meal that earns its place in the rotation because the oven does most of the work.

And in this case, it gives a slightly disappointing packet of lamb chops a very good second act.